Plum vs Mamaearth Face Wash: Which Is Better for Your Skin? 

Two of the best-selling face washes currently in the Indian skin care market are the Mamaearth Vitamin C Face Wash and the Plum Green Tea Pore Cleansing Face Wash. These are affordable, “clean” face washes that make their way into every list of the best face washes for their skin concerns. But this is precisely the reason why everyone finds it so difficult to choose between them.

The short version: these two products aren’t really solving the same problem. One is built to brighten dull, tan-prone skin. The other is built to control oil and clear acne-prone pores. Once you know which concern you actually have, the choice gets a lot easier.

Instant Judgment

Mamaearth Vitamin C Face Wash should be chosen if you have dullness, uneven skin tone, or light tanning as your primary concern.

Plum Green Tea Pore Cleansing Face Wash should be chosen if you have oily skin, clogged pores, or acne as your primary concern.

Comparison Chart: Plum vs Mamaearth Face Wash

Mamaearth Vitamin C Face Wash — Closer Look

The key ingredients of Mamaearth’s formulation are Vitamin C and turmeric that have the ability to make the skin tone even and give it a subtle glow without being an acne treatment product. This product does not claim to be a solution for pimpled skin but more of a cleansing agent and contains no sulfates and parabens making it safer for day-to-day use by people with dry or normal skin types.

Where it works great:

• Tired looking skin
• Dull skin
• Uneven skin tone
• For a cleansing agent, not for treatment
• Sulfate free formulas

Weaknesses of the product:

• It lacks any exfoliating or pore unclogging ingredient
• It is not effective enough to work alone on any active acne or extra oily skin
• Brightening effects of the face wash are slow and gentle

Plum Green Tea Pore Cleansing Face Wash — Closer Look

Plum’s face wash is more proactive about it. The glycolic acid acts on the outermost layer of the skin, thus helping in clearing the blocked pores and improving any dullness caused due to the dead skin cells, and the green tea extracts provide anti-inflammatory and antioxidant properties – actually very beneficial for those who get a lot of breakouts.

Where it works great:

• Oily and acne-prone skin
• Clogged pores, blackheads, and rough texture
• People who want visible oil control, not just a “clean” feeling

Weaknesses of the product:

• It contains SLES, therefore, it’s not a sulfate-free product – those with very sensitive skin should do a patch test first
• Glycolic acid may be somewhat drying when used excessively, particularly during the winter season
• Doesn’t work well if dullness is your primary problem, instead of being oily or having acne

Plum vs Mamaearth: Which Is Better For Your Skin Concern?

• Skin prone to oiliness and acne: Plum comes out on top. It is more effective against sebum and clogged pores than the Mamaearth product because of its composition with glycolic acid and green tea.
• Skin that is dull or prone to tanning: Mamaearth will work better. Vitamin C and turmeric are the best solution to improve the appearance of your skin, whereas the Plum face wash won’t address this issue.
• Sensitive skin: Mamaearth has an advantage as it is sulfate-free, but those who have sensitive skin need to test both products first because of the active components of both (either Vitamin C or glycolic acid) that may sometimes cause irritation.
• Budget: Plum is slightly cheaper per ml and is available in smaller sizes (50ml).
• Gentle cleansing every day: For this purpose, Mamaearth will be a little gentler on the skin than the other.

Best Recommendation for your skin

Oily, acne prone, or combination skin -> Plum Green Tea Pore Cleansing Face Wash

Dull, uneven, or normal-to-dry skin -> Mamaearth Vitamin C Face Wash

Both oiliness and dullness -> Think about alternating – Plum a few days a week to control oil and Mamaearth the rest of the days

Conclusion

There is no one best product here since it all depends on the condition of your skin. If oiliness and breakouts are your major problem, the exfoliating green tea based formulation by Plum will be your better option. If your skin is more dull and uneven than oily, the Vitamin C face wash by Mamaearth is for you.

Also Read:

• 5 Best Face Washes for Oily Skin and Pimples for Women
• Top 10 Face Wash for Men’s Oily Skin
• The Importance of Hygiene and Safety Standards in Professional Beauty Services

Disclaimer:  Ingredients and pricing are subject to change by the manufacturers. Always check the current pack for the latest ingredient list, and patch-test any new product before regular use.